Generalization Journey — Part 1

Have you ever noticed that your dog will perform a behavior in one context but then not in another? This can seem like a puzzling phenomenon in dog training, but is actually a common and expected response. Dogs need lots of practice in order to generalize trained behaviors: that is, to be able to perform the behaviors anywhere and in any circumstances. Your dog needs to figure out exactly which factors are and are not relevant to each behavior you are trying to teach. By process of elimination, you help your dog zero in on the precise behavior you’re training. For example, when you give the signal for your dog to sit, you want your dog to sit no matter where you are, what the environment is, what position you are in, how far you are from your dog, what your facial expression is, and so forth. This post is the first in a series that will give you systematic ways to vary aspects of training so that your dog can be successful in performing his various trained behaviors in any context.

To minimize the potential for your dog to make associations you don’t want, change just ONE thing at a time. Each change gives your dog the opportunity to learn what the behavior is NOT related to: not location, your posture, what your hand is doing, the weather, the smell of dinner cooking… It’s amazing what associations dogs can make, whether we intended it or not!

When you change something in the training environment, be prepared for your dog to regress briefly while he tests things and figures out what is going on. Any time you “change the picture” for your dog, you may need to back up in the training steps for any given exercise, even to the point of re-teaching the exercise from scratch if necessary. For example, if you have trained a 20 second Sit/Stay at home, you may need to back up to only a couple of seconds when beginning to train a Sit/Stay in a new location. Don’t worry, the more you work on variations, the faster your dog will get back to levels that were achieved in a different context.

The ideas in this blog series have been greatly aided in organization by the wonderful book The Thinking Dog: Crossover to Clicker Training by Gail Tamases Fisher.

Variation 1: Your Posture and Expression

Choose an exercise and change your posture and expression. This includes sitting, standing, crouching, kneeling, lying down, bending over. Change your facial expression, the direction your head is turned, where you’re looking (dogs can pick womandoingyogaup our subtle eye movements), eye contact (from you) or no eye contact, glasses on or off, sunglasses on. Each change may alter your dog’s perception of the exercise, making it a different exercise. Also vary your arm position: arms crossed, uncrossed, hanging at your sides, over your head, on your hips, and so forth. Always be prepared to backtrack to help your dog figure out what is going on, and be sure to alter just one thing at a time.


Stay tuned for Part 2 of Generalization Journey. Happy training!

(Image courtesy of imagerymajestic /

2 thoughts on “Generalization Journey — Part 1”

  1. Everything is very open with a very clear clarification of the
    issues. It was definitely informative. Your website is useful.

    Many thanks for sharing!

    1. Savvy Canines of AZ says:

      Thanks for your kind words! We’re glad you stopped by our site!

Comments are closed.

Click any image to enlarge.

Our Clients Say

“The Savvy Canines trainers are knowledgeable, consistent, and competent and love dogs. Phyllis provides a flexible schedule, comes to my home, and the cost is reasonable and well worth it. The classes twice a month are great for Molly to meet other people and dogs and to show off what she has learned. Molly and I are very pleased with the training from Savvy Canines.”—Diane and “Molly”
“The positive reinforcement we get from trainers at Savvy Canines of Arizona is exceptional, always so patient and helpful. Chloe is a work in progress, but she does make life easier by picking up dropped objects. We could not have done this on our own.” —Susan and "Chloe"
“Minnie and I have worked with Savvy Canines since its inception. From the first day Minnie has loved Phyllis and the training sessions with her. Minnie loves the challenges, the games (and the attention). The one service that sets Savvy Canines apart from other training programs is the individual attention to each client. They work around your schedule, find creative ways to get tasks accomplished, and do it all in a professional, caring way. Minnie and I LOVE the trainers and the time spent learning new tasks. Thank you Savvy Canines. You are pawsitively the BEST!”—Reva and “Minnie”
“Our instructor helps both human and animal understand and accommodate to one another. We were also impressed that Kay carries out her training sessions with a kind, gentle approach—even with the pet owner!” —Pamela and Roger H. and "Fred" and "Molly"
“The clicker training technique Savvy Canines teaches is very simple, yet powerful. Dogs actually enjoy learning tasks their partners want them to do when the clicker is used properly.”—George and “Rover”
“Kay (our instructor) is terrific in helping people understand their canine friends. She has a real understanding of dog behavior and is able to quickly tune in to what is going on in a human-dog relationship.” —Pamela H. and "Molly"
"Working with Sarah is the most important thing in my life. The gentle, positive training of Savvy Canines continues to increase the amazing bond between us. As my disabilities increase, Sarah is learning new ways to help me, both at home and out in public."—Susan N. and “Sarah”
"We own and train Australian Shepherds, and when I became disabled, my wife thought I might benefit from a Service Dog. She made a call, and I was surprised when Phyllis Allen (whom I had seen on a TV program about service dogs) came to my house to tell us about the Service Dog training program. She explained the program, assessed my needs, and met the dog I intended to use for training. I was impressed that she would come to my home to meet us and to explain how the program worked. Phyllis is a superb teacher. Savvy Canines uses a positive training method called “clicker training.” Before I met Phyllis I had never used the clicker method, and I am now convinced that it is one of the best training tools for teaching a dog complex tasks. It is definitely a thing of beauty when your dog “gets it” and accomplishes a new skill."—Bruce and “Elwood”
"I am slowly getting back into the world as I recover from my neurological disorder, and this journey toward recovery has been greatly accelerated by training and living with my Service Dog. I spoke with people who had been devastated by their illnesses and had become virtual shut-ins, and I observed how training and living with a Service Dog changed them. Their lives were transformed by getting back into the world; these folks now have the confidence to “fight the good fight.” Then one day I saw that same confidence in myself. I now go just about everywhere with my Service Dog. I want to thank Phyllis Allan and Savvy Canines for being so amazingly kind and patient with me and my dog. I would definitely recommend Savvy Canines of Arizona to anyone who is considering training a Service Dog."—Bruce and “Elwood”
Our trainer has helped us establish a fantastic rapport with our dog! The clicker training has been great. Our dog is attuned to our needs and anticipates my commands for helping close doors on the cabinets and the refrigerator, and thoroughly enjoys adjusting the pedals on my wheelchair! We have been especially pleased with our trainer's willingness to work around our schedule because of my medical problems.—Mr. and Mrs. Larson
Scroll to Top